Chocolate Chip Cookies with Marshmallow (vegan)

BIG and showy, these vegan chocolate chip cookies with marshmallow are a cookie lovers dream come true. Stuffed with melted pools of chocolate and gooey toasted marshmallow, every bite is pure decadence. Just like my eggless peanut butter cookies, they're an epic twist on a beloved classic.

Grandma's famous chocolate chip cookies are soft and chewy, stuffed with chocolate chips, and are deliciously addictive. I've been making her recipe for decades with a few vegan swaps. These epic vegan chocolate chip and marshmallow cookie cups are a nod to grandma's classic chocolate chip cookie recipe with a little s'mores on top (ha ha)!

How to make vegan chocolate chunk cookies

It can be a little trickier to veganize baking recipes than cooking recipes because they are made without eggs and without dairy and that can change the flavor and texture of baking. However, once you get the hang of it, it's pretty easy. Here's what I did for this recipe:

Butter: butter adds flavour, tenderness, and richness. Start with any flavourful vegan stick butter or margarine at room temperature (sitting out for ~1 - 2 hours). Room temperature butter emulsifies with the sugar more evenly and becomes creamy and light which impacts the texture of the cookies.

PRO TIP: If you're in a rush to eat chocolate chip cookies (and who isn't!), use this tip to speed up the softening process. Cut the butter sticks into slices, separate them into a medium mixing bowl, and leave on the counter while you gather and measure your other ingredients giving them time to soften. Additionally, you can cover the bowl with a hot damp towel (creating a warm cave) to speed things along.

Vegan Egg Replacement: eggs offer structure to the cookies, but you can easily swap out any of these replacements with 'egg'cellent results: golden flax egg, aquafaba or Bob's Red Mill egg replacement.

Where to find vegan chocolate

Dairy-free Chocolate: there are so many choices for dairy-free chocolate nowadays - luckily! I like the Enjoy Life brand of chocolate - it's delicious and easy to find at most grocery stores in the baking aisle (sometimes in the Natural Food aisle). Most big brands have a dairy-free version of chocolate chips/chunks including Costco Kirkland Brand, Baker's semi sweet, Guittard semi sweet, and Trader Joe's - just check the label.*

The mini chocolate chips from Enjoy Life are perfect in my most-requested recipe: Vegan Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Banana Bread!

Allergen Tip: sometimes the chocolate chip package will say 'may contain milk or milk products' which typically means it is made in a facility that uses milk/milk products. But if milk or milk products (whey, butter, etc) are not listed in the ingredients, you should be good to go.

Fun Fact: Grandma's sister gave her this chocolate chip cookie recipe in 1934. Apparently, the original recipe used Crisco with a sprinkle of salt and 2 chopped squares of Baker's semi-sweet chocolate. So if you have a favourite dairy-free chocolate bar, chop it up into chunks and use that in place of the chocolate chips!

Are marshmallows vegan?

Yup, there are vegan marshmallows, and they are are scrumptious. I love Dandies! You can find them easily now in many grocery stores or online. There are other vegan brands available too, like Trader Joe's brand. (I use half a large marshmallow or tear it into smaller pieces.)

Baking Tips and Cookie Testing

Although I've been baking this recipe for eons, these cookie cups are BIG so I did some extra recipe testing to make sure they were perfect. What I found out was almost everything worked with yummy results!

Egg Replacements - flax egg (1 tbsp golden flax, 3 tbsp warm water), aqua faba (2-3 tbsp), and Bob's Red Mill Egg Replacement - all good. Typically I use a flax egg or aqua faba in baking because I always have these ingredients on hand.

These cookie cups have no chill (tee hee) - chilling the dough didn't make a huge difference in this case because the cookies are baked in cups which prevents them from spreading. The texture was very similar and equally enjoyable with and without chilling. Typically I do chill the cookie balls for 10-20 minutes before baking though.

When the cookies are slightly under baked, they are super chewy and gooey (my future son-in-law's favourite). However, the middle tends to sink upon cooling (partly because of the weight of the extra chocolate chunks and the marshmallow on top a tender crumb). This still produces a very chewy tasty cookie, but it's not as pretty. A few more minutes in the oven solves this.

Mixing the Dough - if you don't have electric beaters, not to worry, you can make these cookies the old fashion way! When mixing by hand, if the dough is not coming together, add another tablespoonful of aqua faba or up to 2 tbsp of plant-based milk. The dough should be moist but stiff.

Storing and Freezing the Cookies

Baked Cookies - Once the cookies have completely cooled, store them in an air-tight container on the counter or in the fridge for up to 5 or 6 days.
Freeze any baked cookies in an air-tight freezer bag for up to 3-4 months.

Unbaked Cookie Balls - Make 12 cookie balls as per the recipe and place on a cookie sheet in the freezer for about 30 minutes. Then transfer the frozen balls to an airtight container and freeze for up to 3 months. I usually note the date and cooking instructions on the container with a piece of masking tape (eg. CCC May 28/2020 - 350º F 13-15 min).
On baking day, bring the balls to room temperature while your oven is preheating, then add the chocolate chunks and marshmallows, and bake as directed.

Other Yummy Vegan Treats

If you love these eggless chocolate chip cookies, you're going to love these other vegan treats:

• Vegan Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Banana Bread
• Eggless Chocolate Cupcakes
• Vegan Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
• Eggless Cinnamon Rolls

Did you make my Epic Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cookie Cup recipe?
I'd love to see them! Please leave a comment below and tag me on Instagram if you take photos!
NEVER MISS A RECIPE: Sign up for my email NEWSLETTER!